Letter from Elizabeth Milligan to Millard Fillmore, June 5, 1844

  1. 250th Gallery
  2. Letter from Elizabeth Milligan to Millard Fillmore, June 5, 1844

The Correspondence of Zachary Taylor and Millard Fillmore is assembling an edition of letters written by or to those men between 1844 and 1853. During that decade, which preceded and included their terms in the White House, the United States expanded its boundaries and enacted reforms while advancing toward civil war. It annexed the Republic of Texas, won control of California and the Southwest through a war with Mexico, passed compromise legislation on slavery, debated women’s and immigrants’ roles in society, and continued forcibly removing Indigenous peoples from their ancestral lands. Taylor and Fillmore helped lead those initiatives and conversations.

Taylor (1784–1850) owned plantations and enslaved people to work them in Kentucky, Louisiana, and Mississippi. A career soldier, he commanded US forces in conflicts against Native peoples, led troops into Texas in 1845, and became a lead general in the Mexican-American War of 1846–48. Military fame propelled him to election as president, on the Whig Party ticket, in 1848. Fillmore (1800–1874), meanwhile, an Erie County, NY, lawyer, served in the New York House and the US House before seeking (and losing) the Whig vice-presidential nomination and the governor’s seat in 1844. He became the University of Buffalo’s founding chancellor in 1846, state comptroller in 1848, and Taylor’s running mate that June. After Taylor died in 1850, he took over as president. In the White House, both men negotiated with Congress over whether the western lands Taylor had helped win from Mexico would permit slavery. The final Compromise of 1850 included California’s admission to statehood with slavery illegal, the organization of the Southwest into territories with slavery allowed, and a divisive new Fugitive Slave Act.

This edition, though designed around two powerful men, features the voices of diverse North Americans. While Taylor was the lead US official in the Texas republic and Mexico, men and women from all three nations told him of their sufferings amid the diplomatic and military crisis. While Fillmore served as New York’s chief financial officer, constituents wrote to him on business including state annuities to Indigenous residents and state funds for Black orphans’ education. During the presidential campaign and administrations, prominent and obscure Americans shared opinions on slavery, disunion, gender, immigration, technology, tariffs, literature, and numerous other topics. Most letters in the edition, as a result, are those written to rather than by the presidents. At a time when literacy among Whites was high and outgoing postage was usually free, people from all walks of life wrote to their leaders, and presidents’ letters became documentary slices of US political, social, economic, and cultural history.

The Taylor-Fillmore project has begun opening access to those primary sources for students, scholars, and all readers. In August 2026, the University of Tennessee Press published the series’ first volume. The Correspondence of Zachary Taylor and Millard Fillmore, volume 1, January 1844–June 1848 features 369 annotated letters (plus 4 enclosures) stretching from the prelude to Texas annexation through the close of the Mexican-American War. Two more volumes will cover the election of 1848 and both presidencies. Volume 1 is available in hardcover, as an ebook, and on JSTOR. In 2027 it will be added to the American Documentary History Collection, a cross-searchable collection of documentary editions by the University of Virginia Press’s Rotunda imprint, and will be released as an open-access pdf in the American University Research Archive.

In this gallery, we share one of the letters from volume 1. In it, artist Elizabeth Milligan reflects on the wonders of nature and on her experiences painting portraits. Having recently painted Dolley Payne Todd Madison on ivory (shown here), she describes that former first lady and former president John Quincy Adams as “links that connect ours with a past age.

Read More
Document
Information

Fredericksburg [VA] June 5th [1844]

My dear Mr. Fillmore,

I was much pleased to receive your kind & friendly letter1 and almost wonder that one so distinguished as yourself should remember an obscure travelling companion. I thank my dear Mrs. Fillmore2 for reminding you of the mission, and sending her remembrance to us, for although I had so little opportunity of cultivating her acquaintance, she is one by whom I shall always be most happy to be remembered.

I came to this place for the purpose of transfering some of the faces of the old dominion [Virginia] to ivory if they will submit to the operation. I find the inhabitants courteous & hospitable, & it is a very agreeable sail from Washington to this place. I do not however anticipate spending so agreable a summer as I ^we^ did in Western N. York, where we enjoyed ourselves g^s^o much riding about among its beautiful lakes and {.} ^waterfalls^   The visit to Niagara will ever be a ^like^ a bright dream to me. I can scarcely believe I have really seen the ‘mighty waters,’ although to you who live almost within hearing of its eternal roar its seems but an every day occurrence to gaze upon it. Have you ever visited the Natural Bridge?3 I have a great disire to see it and then, I shall have viewed both wonders of our beautiful land.

I am told there is great sublimity in the stillness around the natural bridge, its wildness and want of cultivation there are no railroads canals or mills to drag the soaring imagination as by a chain to the earth. I felt this very much at Niagara   I would have glady dispensed with those magnificent Hotels and all the facilities of travel, to have looked upon the scenery in its primitive grandeur. A gentleman once told me when he first gazed upon the natural Bridge and was com^pletety^ absorbed by the still sublimity of the scene fearing almost to breathe—a lady came up to him and asked him if would have a piece of bread & ham, he tumbled down most rapidly from the clouds, wishing the lady any where with her bread & ham but at the Natural Bridge. Our poetic soarings are very short lived in this eating plodding world.

Just before I left home, I had the pleasure of taking Mrs. Madison likeness,4 and I assure you I found her a most interesting sitter. She and J. Q. Adams5 seem to be the links that connect ours with a past age. Mrs. Madison is a most astonishing woman being now 86. and she does not look to be more than 50. and she enjoys life with all the zest of a girl of fifteen, she loves the society of the young. I should like very much my dear Sir, to shew to yourself & Mrs. Fillmore the likeness which I have taken of the dear old lady it is thought to resemble her very much. I hope it will not be long before you visit Washington, when I shall be enabled to do so.

My sister Sally6 has a very strong inclination to take a trip to Indiana some near relations of o[urs] have urgently invited some of us to return with the member from their district,7 who has kindly offered to take her under his charge, but I think should she take the route they propose she would be very likely to end her journey in Buffalo, she so frequently speaks of her visit there. But I do not think it probable she will leave home as her health seems to be very well established.

I shall be most happy to receive a letter from yourself and Mrs. Fillmore whenever you can write conveniently, and with the kindest regards to your lady & family beleiv me Ever Yours with esteem & respect

E. Milligan

Notes & Annotations

Elizabeth Milligan (1813–93) was a Washington artist whose mediums included paint on ivory. She met the Fillmores while traveling in upstate New York in summer 1843. In 1854 she married John S. Gulick (1817–84), whom MF had appointed a navy purser in 1851.

1. MF to Milligan, Mar. 10, 1844.

2. Abigail Powers (1798–1853), born in Stillwater, NY, taught at schools in and near Sempronius. Beginning in the winter of 1818–19, she and MF studied together at New Hope Academy, where she may have been his teacher. After their 1826 wedding, they settled in Aurora, Erie County. Teaching classes in their home and in the village school, she became the first president’s wife to work for pay while married. During most of MF’s political career, she maintained their household in Buffalo, where they moved in 1830, but visited him in Washington and served as an important advisor. She moved with him to Albany after his election as state comptroller in 1847. Moving into the White House in 1850, she received callers and presided over dinners and receptions whenever possible but occasionally delegated hosting duties to daughter Mary Abigail. A pianist, harpist, and avid reader, Abigail partnered with MF to develop the first White House library. She died of pneumonia on Mar. 30, 1853. (This note incorporates research by Elizabeth Lorelei Thacker-Estrada for the forthcoming biography Abigail Powers Fillmore: The Light of the White House.)

3. Located in (and the namesake of) Rockbridge County, VA, Natural Bridge is a limestone arch 215 feet tall by 90 feet wide over Cedar Creek. The Monacan people recognized it as a sacred site before Europeans’ arrival. In 1774 Thomas Jefferson purchased the bridge and surrounding land from King George III. In Notes on the State of Virginia (1785), he called it “the most sublime of Nature’s works.”

4. Born in Guilford County, NC, Dolley Payne (1768–1849) moved to Hanover County, VA, as an infant and to Philadelphia in 1783. She married John Todd Jr. (1763–93) and, in 1794, James Madison (1751–1836). In 1801–17, with James serving as secretary of state and president, they divided their time between Montpelier plantation, Orange County, VA, and Washington. As White House hostess, Dolley deftly presided over weekly levees that brought together James’s political allies and adversaries. As a widow, she sold Montpelier and moved back to Washington. Milligan’s portrait of her, now at the Princeton University Library, is a miniature painted on ivory, measuring 3 5⁄8 by 2 7⁄8 inches.

5. Born in Braintree, MA, John Quincy Adams (1767–1848) married Louisa Johnson (1775–1852). He served in various diplomatic posts; in the US Senate, 1803–8; and as secretary of state, 1817–25, before becoming president, 1825–29. Defeated for reelection by Andrew Jackson, he served in the US House, 1831–48. Early on a Federalist, Adams became a Whig in 1834. He opposed Texas annexation and the spread of slavery. He suffered a stroke during a House debate on Feb. 21, 1848, and died in the Capitol two days later.

6. Washingtonian Sarah B. “Sally” Milligan (1823–99) was the younger of Elizabeth’s two younger sisters. In 1856 she and another sister sold land in Fauquier County, VA, to John S. Gulick. She likely was one of the “Misses Milligan” who, according to newspaper advertisements, ran the Ringwood Female School there (in Auburn, then Catlett) from before 1856 until at least 1876.

7. Despite the Indiana reference, Milligan possibly refers to Thomas J. Paterson (1805–85), who franked this letter and who represented the district that included Rochester, NY, in the US House, 1843–45. Born in Lisle, NY, he had moved as a child to Parma and then Rochester. There he became a merchant and miller before the Panic of 1837 ruined his milling business. A Whig, he was elected city supervisor in 1838. After his congressional term, he became a land agent.

Institution(s):

The Correspondence of Zachary Taylor and Millard Fillmore is a project of the Center for Congressional and Presidential Studies at American University.

It has received generous grant support from the National Historical Publications and Records Commission; the National Endowment for the Humanities; the Summerlee Foundation; The Gladys Krieble Delmas Foundation; the Watson-Brown Foundation; Delaplaine Foundation, Inc.; and the William G. Pomeroy Foundation. (Any views, findings, conclusions, or recommendations expressed in this Web resource do not necessarily represent those of the National Endowment for the Humanities.)

Editor(s):

Michael David Cohen and Amy Larrabee Cotz

Source Note

ALS. Millard Fillmore Papers, State University of New York at Oswego. Millard Fillmore Papers, ed. Lester W. Smith (Buffalo, NY: Buffalo & Erie County Historical Society and State Univ. College at Oswego, NY, 1975), microfilm, reel 54. Addressed to Buffalo. Franked by Thomas J. Paterson. Postmarked Washington, June 7.

Editorial Process & Document History

The editors of the Taylor-Fillmore project believe that the best way to learn history is from the words of those who made it. They therefore present the letters as accurately as possible while maximizing ease of reading. The edition features transcribed and painstakingly proofread texts that reproduce the authors’ spelling, capitalization, and punctuation. Text that is unreadable because of damage but clear from context appears in brackets; text that the editors have supplied, such as a missing year or the expansion of an abbreviation, appears in brackets and italics; an illegible character is represented by “{.}”. Strikethroughs indicate cancellations, carets (^) surround insertions, and three spaces indicate a sentence break without punctuation. Numbered notes provide background and contextual information, including short biographies of all people, that enable twenty-first-century readers to understand the nineteenth-century documents. Those annotations draw on the editors’ extensive primary and secondary research.

Elizabeth Milligan’s manuscript letter is in the Millard Fillmore Papers at the State University of New York at Oswego. Images of it were included in the microfilm Millard Fillmore Papers, published in 1975. The Correspondence of Zachary Taylor and Millard Fillmore features the first available transcription.

Additional Details

Image, Courtesy of Princeton University Library, is Elizabeth Milligan, Dolley Madison, 1844, oil on ivory, 9.5 × 7.5 cm, Special Collections, Princeton University Library, https://www.princeton.edu/~graphicarts/2009/07/dolley_madison.html.

Welch v. Tufts lawsuit (1760)

The case is an appeal heard before the Massachusetts Superior Court of Judicature, the highest court in Massachusetts prior to the American...

The Association for Documentary Editing

The ADE brings historical documents to life by helping editors preserve, interpret, and share important records from the past with the public.